1.
“Over the past ten years I have had the privilege of
working with one of the nation’s top paranormal investigative teams run by
one of the few expert’s in the field (although she says there are no experts
it’s an ever-changing subject).” http://www.ghostexas.org/meet.htm
|
Appeal
to Misleading Authority
By
saying that he is working with an expert in the field of ‘paranormal
investigation’ is somewhat of an appeal to misleading authority as the field
of paranormal investigation is a pseudoscience. Saying that you’re an expert
in paranormal investigation is about the same as saying you are an expert in
reading the movement of the stars. It takes no certification and no
credentials whatsoever to claim you’re an expert in the field, although to
her credit, she claims she’s not truly an expert in the field as it is ‘ever
changing’.
|
2.
Many times, what people are going through is quite
frightening and I hope to ease their emotions by helping them understand
what is actually happening. Having three kids of my own and living in a
haunted home with them has given me a special insight to what it’s like
dealing with a family and the paranormal which helps me bring that added
touch of understanding in these frightening situations.”
|
Emotional
Appeal
Saying
that people who live in haunted houses are frightened and implying that they
‘need to be rescued’ is an emotional appeal. X is true because it works for
the good of society, with ‘x’ being paranormal investigation. One of the
things I find most baffling about this statement is the fact that she openly
admits that she is living in a haunted house with her children. If you have
children. Then why are you living in an alleged haunted house where they
could very easily get emotionally harmed?! I get that it’s probably more
complicated than that but come on!
|
3.
Matt and his
wife did a wonderful job on helping us find out who and what was in our
house. They got rid of our demon ghost and left our good ones. My husband and
I were very pleased with their professional ways. If I ever need
assistance again I will call them back. I highly recommend Matt and
Rachael. Again, thank you.
http://www.ghostexas.org/Letter1.htm
|
Wishful
Thinking
This
one is just plain silly, and honestly I wouldn’t be surprised if this man was
completely made up. ‘They got rid of our demon ghost and left our good ones’
What
the fuck does that even mean?!
Thank
goodness they took care of that nasty demon ghost that was making noises in
the middle of the night and thank goodness they left the friendly ones! I
don’t know what they would’ve done had they taken the friendly ghosts as well!
|
4.
After the investigation
was competed, they decided a cleansing would be necessary in order to bring
peace back to our home. This is a Christian based ceremony which
utilizes prayer and the anointing of all entrances & exits in the home.
http://www.ghostexas.org/Letter3.htm
|
Scope
Fallacy
The
biggest problem that I have with this example is the use of the phrase ‘Christian-based’
without saying what branch or denominations of Christians use this alleged
practice. Saying something is ‘Christian-based’ implies that all Christians use
this practice without exception, which is not the case. It’s also highly
likely it is referred to as Christian-based because it is an appeal to the
credibility of Christianity.
|
5.
With the experiences of our investigator coupled
with the equipment and events of the night. GHoST deemed the home to have
paranormal activity and a in depth home cleansing was needed. After
discussing with the $$$ they agreed, and a cleansing was performed.
http://www.ghostexas.org/case019.htm
|
Accident
Wait,
I thought it said they don’t accept monetary donations, yet in this example
says they collected payment? This shows that the one instance in which they
didn’t charge is not represented to the whole.
|
This blog will be filled with data analysis samples created by students in my COMM 274 class at TLU. You will see a variety of types of rhetorical analysis methods on display here.
Links to rhetorical tools:
Here are links to the rhetorical tools used in this class:
Monday, February 26, 2018
GHoST Fallacies
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment