Links to rhetorical tools:

Here are links to the rhetorical tools used in this class:

Schemes & Tropes -- Perelman & Olbrechts-Tyteca -- Fallacies -- Burke -- Rhetorical Toolbox -- Conspiracy Rhetorics

Thursday, February 23, 2017

The Morning of the Magicians





Quality
The rare and unique is better 
“the limited nature of physical structure of the Universe:the non existence of atoms; restricted sources of fundamental energy; the inability of a mathematical formula to yield more than it already contains; the futility of intuition; the narrowness and absolutely mechanical nature of a Mans internal world; these were the things that scientists believed in, and this attitude of mind applied to everything and created the climate which permeated every branch of knowledge in this century” pg 40 
he is saying that all of these bizarre and unique things that happen in our universe is good 
Amplification 
Divide a whole into parts 
“We believe that the alchemist feels a kind of transmutation taking place within himself…” 
pg 108

“more than a hundred books on alchemy are known to exist..” pg 109 

“The alchemists speak of the necessity of distilling water to be used in the preparation of the elixir…” pg 110

“These are some of the alchemist achievements..” pg 111


The whole chapter is just basically breaking apart alchemy and alchemists into different parts and analyzing it 
Single 
One event is an example
“In the year 1910 there lived in New York, a little bourgeois apartment in the Bronx, a little man..” 
pg 142
The chapter goes on to tell this extremely long story about this man who wrote about “the vanished civilizations” 

2 comments:

  1. Based on what I have seen with the Fallacies blog post and this one, you have a good sense of what nonsense the author is trying to peddle. Alchemy and magic and "vanished civilizations" sound vivid, interesting, and enticing to the innocent and unaware reader, slowly tempting them to read more until the poor reader becomes a Conspiracy Nut. I think you have a good basis for an argument. Perhaps incorporate the Salem Witch trials or other histories in connection with the theme?

    ReplyDelete
  2. It seems, specifically looking at the long quote on page 40, that the author here likes to use complex vocabulary and long, drawn out explanations to make it seem like the ideas that he is discussing are important and things that other people talk about as well.

    ReplyDelete