Term:
|
Definition:
|
Quote(s):
|
Explanation:
|
Facts/truths
(Observed)
|
Agreed upon reality.
Observed.
Concrete data.
|
“We
sit back approx.125ft”
“I
walked out to end of drive, approx. 200 ft.”
“w/
faint toe marks approx. 12 inches”
|
Uses
specific numbers to back up what she has learned.
|
Presumptions
|
The
normal
Based
on a reference group or experience
|
“This
is the same dog that almost went thru a screen door to attack the bear by our
feeder a few weeks ago.”
|
Given
the events that have happened, claiming her dog was behaving strangely.
|
Presence
|
Time
Making
it feel urgent.
Space
Making
it feel close.
|
“It
was sunny day. We sit back approx.125ft from the road.
I
saw a very black humanoid shape walking on two legs go past our driveway. It
was half bent over then straightened up. It had longs arms swinging. The head
was turned away & appeared to have very short neck & roundish head
from that angle.”
|
She
uses time and space to describe the scene, she says it was a sunny day, how
far from the road she was and what she saw.
|
Interpretation
|
Specific
Choices. Choose between alternatives.
|
“I
saw a very black humanoid shape walking on two legs go past our driveway. It
was half bent over then straightened up. It had longs arms swinging. The head
was turned away & appeared to have very short neck & roundish head
from that angle. I said to myself, "That looks like a chimp!”
|
She
interprets and compares what she sees to a chimp-monkey.
|
Succession
|
A
cause-and-effect argument.
|
“Later
in day I went out to that area with my small dog. She refused to even walk
and was trembling.”
|
Due
to the presence of the creature, the dog did not want to walk where it had
been.
|
Intention
|
Various
acts reveal a unified essence.
|
“I
noticed an area of bent weeds that would have been where the creature had
exited our woods, going into a small ditch then back up to get onto road
before walking past our drive. On the roadside, in the direction I saw it
going, there were 3 barefoot heel depressions w/ faint toe marks approx. 12
inches long. The area was dry with fine gravel so not a clear print.”
|
She
was able to paint a whole picture of the creature and the situation because
of the knowledge she had been getting.
|
Example
Dissociation
|
Event/s
reveal/s a rule or reality.
(breaking
ideas into sets of philosophical pairs like appearance/reality to develop and
explain a new idea)
|
“The
week before, I had heard twigs snapping & weeds moving behind my fenced
garden. This approx. 40 ft from the front porch where I often sit. The dog
barked.”
“I
said to myself, "That looks like a chimp!". I watched for it for
approx.12 seconds until it disappeared behind trees going east on road. There
are spots that I can see thru the trees to the neighbors drive, so I was
looking for it to either go up the drive or continue on road.”
|
Uses
more than one event to describe her experiences.
She
explains what she saw as a chimp to equate it to something we have
seen before.
|
This blog will be filled with data analysis samples created by students in my COMM 274 class at TLU. You will see a variety of types of rhetorical analysis methods on display here.
Links to rhetorical tools:
Here are links to the rhetorical tools used in this class:
Thursday, February 27, 2020
Bigfoot: P-OT Blog Post
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
You have a lot of good tools to use to make your thesis! A lot of what you pulled from the report is about the small dog and there seems to be a lot of fear being induced in the article from the quotes that were pulled out. I wonder if her dog wasn't with her and behaving scared, then if the author would still believe that this instance was a bigfoot sighting?
ReplyDeleteI wasn't sure which post you used, but I think you found some good examples of fallacies and arguments. I really like all the things you found on the dog being with her, it was very interesting and kind of funny! I think that the fact that she uses measurements could possibly be supposed instead of fact but that could be wrong on my part.
ReplyDelete