Szemeredy - Perelman Arguments

Perelman Argument	Article Connections
Facts/Truth – Supposed	By using newspaper articles and police reports, it is assumed that Scarsi believes these accounts to be the truth when in reality, they are assumptions of the actual events based on fabrications of the mind and excitement of the media.
Locus of Quantity	There are more incidents that allow the connection between Ripper and Szemeredy than those of quality which would suggest that there are too many coincidences.
Presence – Aggregation	The many different anecdotes all are to be assumed that they add up to make up the whole.
Analysis – Philosophical	All of the reasons behind why Szemeredy is the Ripper are based on the supposed facts of the media and the police reports.
Inclusion	Each report is a testament to the larger idea of Szemeredy's guilt.
Coexistence – Intention	Scarsi assumed that all the reports about Szemeredy make up his entire character as staed in the section “What have we got here?”