Perelman
|
Fallacies
|
Figures, schemes, tropes, visual, typography
|
Burke
|
Premises-Concrete hierarchies to promote the success of past
movements and their success to relate it to animal rights, as it is the only
thing left to do. “We’ve established women’s rights, children’s rights, gay
rights, and I think the final frontier of social evolution is animal rights.”
|
Challenging authorities on behalf of people’s needs and interests
that aren’t even relevant. Red Herring: “God gave man dominion over the fish
and the sea, and over the fowls of the air, and over the cattle, but imposed
no voluntary subjection of one man to another.”
|
Meat is murder, now anytime someone eats meat they are now going to
think of murder, it acts as a shock to society, somewhat maybe even too
shocking.
|
PETA, people for the ethical treatment of animals, the most visible
group promoting animal rights, and one of the most successful contemporary
social movement organizations commonly makes use of moral claims as a framing
technique.
|
Order loci, lamb of god, choose life, go vegetarian. This is
submitting to the idea of most important to least important, but because the
important is so important to some people, they are more than likely going to
want to agree.
|
“It’s not a movement you need to join by sending a donation. It’s a movement
you can join at your next meal.” This acts as a black or white, it is saying
that you no longer have to pay any money to join our movement, but you can
just not eat meat at your next meal to save those animals that could’ve been
on your plate.
|
“Lamb of God, choose life, go vegetarian” Arrangement climax, drawing
in people who believe that in God or religion, visually seeing the bloody
sheep hanging in the background, the sheep represents peace or cleansed, then
saying choose life making people now keep interested because of them wanting
to believe in life, then leaving them on the note of vegetarianism.
|
Moral Protesters who are agents in social movements, 50,000 people
are actively in, and a budget of $13.4 million
|
The contemptuous comparison, “To animals all people are nazis”
comparing humans to nazi’s and offending anyone who reads this. Placing a
terrible situation that happened to humans in comparison with animals to get
people to try and realize how bad this situation actually is.
|
“holocaust on your plate” “Meat is murder” “Jesus was a vegetarian”-
Appeal to tradition
|
Visually placing men in concentration camps, against chickens in
their stall nests, this is cruel to those that suffered in the holocaust
because those are real people, animals do not have a decision or affect by
displaying their stuggles.
|
The campaign moves towards trying to move everyone on board with them,
they then move to target groups, men, women, middle aged, 18 – 27, religion, American
affiliation
|
“Proud to be a vegetarian American” appealing to tradition, relating
people to the idea of being American, making the claim that if you are American,
you will support the idea of becoming vegetarian and help the animals.
|
I see this movement as an Epic, all these animals are being killed
and slaughtered, and PETA trys to come and swoop in to save the animals, and
save the humans from being “terrible” or not being American, or not being
ethical people.
|
||
This blog will be filled with data analysis samples created by students in my COMM 274 class at TLU. You will see a variety of types of rhetorical analysis methods on display here.
Links to rhetorical tools:
Here are links to the rhetorical tools used in this class:
Thursday, April 21, 2016
Animal Rights Mobilization Data Table
Wednesday, April 6, 2016
Topics for final project
Pick a social movement and sign up in comments, first-come, first-served, as always. I have a link to an academic article on your movement to help you get started on some better data than a wiki or google search.
See the syllabus for assignment details.
Black Power
Amsterdam Squatters
Pacifism in Postwar Japan
Save Darfur
Clayoquot Sound Rainforest
Animal Rights Mobilization
SDS
Scandinavian Global Justice
Fair Trade
Australian Women's Movement
Project 10
Georgia Temperance
Brazilian Landless Workers
Antiwar Feminist Performance Activism
Free Chol Sul Lee
Knights of Labor
Hugo Chavez' Revolution
20s Indiana KKK
Solidarity
East Germany 1989
N30
Catholic Workers
Queer Nation
French Teachers
Royal York Strike
Black Lives Matter
WTO
Occupy Wall Street
Arab Spring
Stonewall
STOP ERA
British Nation of Islam
See the syllabus for assignment details.
Black Power
Amsterdam Squatters
Pacifism in Postwar Japan
Save Darfur
Clayoquot Sound Rainforest
Animal Rights Mobilization
SDS
Scandinavian Global Justice
Fair Trade
Australian Women's Movement
Project 10
Georgia Temperance
Brazilian Landless Workers
Antiwar Feminist Performance Activism
Free Chol Sul Lee
Knights of Labor
Hugo Chavez' Revolution
20s Indiana KKK
Solidarity
East Germany 1989
N30
Catholic Workers
Queer Nation
French Teachers
Royal York Strike
Black Lives Matter
WTO
Occupy Wall Street
Arab Spring
Stonewall
STOP ERA
British Nation of Islam
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)